One Sentence, 208,000 Petitions: DHS Moves to End “Deference” in H-1B and Other Extensions
Some of the biggest immigration changes arrive in the smallest details. In this case, the proposed federal rule intends to delete a single sentence from the US immigration regulations, and it could change how every H-1B extension is reviewed from now on. Here, our EB-1A experts have dived into explaining and analyzing this important proposal in detail.
What DHS proposed
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) proposed removing the rule that tells USCIS to defer to its own earlier approval when an employer files to extend a worker’s status. The proposal carries the title “Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility,” and was published on October 14, 2026, under docket USCIS-2026-0529. DHS would delete 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5) and leave the paragraph.
The brevity is deceptive. That single deletion touches every Form I-129 extension, including H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, E and other nonimmigrant worker petitions. Public comments were due Friday, November 13, 2026, so the comment window has now closed.
What “deference” means
Deference is a courtesy USCIS extends to itself. When it reviews an I-129 involving the same parties and the same underlying facts as one it already approved, it gives weight to the earlier decision. An officer may depart only for a material error in the prior approval, a material change in circumstances or eligibility requirements, or new material information that adversely affects eligibility.
The practical effect would be large. If finalized, an officer could still consider an earlier approval but would not have to treat it as the starting point. The firm’s analysis adds that current USCIS guidance requires officers to acknowledge the prior approval, explain why deference does not apply, obtain supervisory approval and give the petitioner a chance to respond, and that those safeguards would disappear along with the regulation.
Deference was never a guarantee. The petitioner still has to file a complete extension with evidence of eligibility.
Why DHS wants it gone
DHS offers three reasons: deference shifts the burden of proof from petitioners to officers, discourages officers from issuing requests for evidence, and lets a questionable first approval become an “anchor” for later filings. DHS says the change would reinforce the petitioner’s burden, allow fuller fact-finding and reduce the risk of carrying an earlier error into later decisions.
What DHS’s own data shows
The proposal’s numbers cut against the idea that deference let many bad petitions through. DHS says historical denial rates showed no statistically significant difference between periods with and without deference. The measurable effect was elsewhere: DHS estimates about 6,044 additional requests for evidence (RFEs) a year. Newsweek reported that the filing itself acknowledges that applications would likely take months longer.
Who would be affected
DHS estimates 208,429 petitions a year could be affected. That figure needs careful reading. It counts potentially eligible Form I-129 petitions across classifications, not individual workers who will lose status.
H-1B workers dominate. DHS says H-1B petitions make up more than 75% of Form I-129 filings. USCIS reported that 77.6% of FY 2025 approvals for continuing H-1B employment went to workers born in India. Small employers are exposed too: 57% of classifiable employers filing H-1B extensions that year were small entities, and the median filed one petition.
A headline that overshoots
The link you supplied speaks of thousands “losing their approval,” but the coverage I read draws a firm line. Great Andhra stresses that the proposal does not mean existing H-1B approvals will be cancelled or that thousands of workers will immediately lose their visas, and that it does not change the basic eligibility requirements. VisaVerge likewise says the effects described are more evidence requests and delays, not an automatic denial.
The risk is more subtle. Great Andhra illustrates it with an Indian IT professional whose employer applies for an extension: officers would be free to examine the case afresh even when the employee, employer and job are unchanged.
What it would mean day to day
The law firm identifies three likely effects: more RFEs on routine extensions, such as specialty occupation questions USCIS already decided, longer processing that pushes cases toward the 240-day work-authorization limit, and delayed travel for visa stamping. A timely filed extension generally lets an H-1B worker keep working for up to 240 days after the I-94 expires, subject to applicable rules.
A policy with a history
Deference has swung back and forth. A 2004 USCIS memo first directed officers to defer, USCIS rescinded it in October 2017, restored it in the Policy Manual in April 2021, and DHS codified it in the H-1B Modernization Final Rule in December 2024, effective January 17, 2025. The firm notes that the 2017-2021 period saw RFEs re-litigating questions USCIS had already approved.
What happens next
Nothing changes yet policy wise. The current regulation remains in force unless a final rule takes effect, and DHS has not said whether or when it will issue one. Employers and workers should keep filing complete, and keep their extensions well-documented.
At GCEB1, our EB-1A consultants are staying tuned to all the latest developments in the US immigration landscape. Get in touch with us if you are looking for personalized mentorship into merit based immigration pathways. We wish you a safe and stress free immigration journey ahead.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What exactly did DHS propose?
To delete 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5), the regulation that tells USCIS to give weight to its earlier approvals in extension petitions.
2. Is the rule final?
No. It is a proposal, and the current deference rule stays in effect unless a final rule takes effect.
3. Will existing H-1B approvals be cancelled?
No. Coverage stresses that the proposal does not cancel existing approvals or change basic eligibility requirements.
4. Who would be affected?
Holders of H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, E and other nonimmigrant worker petitions filed on Form I-129, with H-1B making up over 75% of filings.
5. How many petitions could be affected?
DHS estimates 208,429 petitions a year. That counts petitions, not individual workers losing status.
6. Would extensions be denied more often?
DHS’s own data found no statistically significant change in denial rates, but it expects about 6,044 more RFEs a year.
7. Why does DHS want to end deference?
It cites the petitioner’s burden of proof, officer fact-finding and program integrity, including the risk of an “anchor” from a questionable first approval.
8. Is the comment period still open?
No. Comments were due November 13, 2026.
9. What can workers and employers do now?
File complete extensions with strong evidence, allow extra time for possible RFEs, plan travel around longer processing, and consult an immigration attorney.
Sources & further readings
- U.S. Department of Homeland Security. “Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility.”
- Reddy Neumann Brown PC. “DHS Proposes to End Deference to Prior Approvals on H-1B and Other I-129 Extensions.” November 2026. https://www.rnlawgroup.com/dhs-proposes-to-end-deference-to-prior-approvals-on-h-1b-and-other-i-129-extensions/.
- Duane Morris LLP. “DHS Proposes to End Deference to Prior Approvals for H-1B, L-1 and Other Form I-129 Extensions.” October 15, 2026. https://www.duanemorris.com/alerts/dhs_proposes_end_deference_prior_approvals_h1b_l1_other_form_I129_extensions_1026.html.
- The Times of India. “US Government Is Proposing One Sentence Change in USCIS Rules That Would Change Every H-1B Visa Extension Form, with Thousands Losing Their Approval.” November 16, 2026. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/technology/tech-news/us-government-is-proposing-one-sentence-change-in-uscis-rules-that-would-change-every-h-1b-visa-extension-form-with-thousands-losing-their-approval/articleshow/135886323.cms.
- Nacionale News. “H-1B Extension Rule: Not in Force; Comments Due Nov. 13.” November 12, 2026. https://www.nacionale.com/en/articles/dhs-proposed-h1b-extension-rule-ending-deference-what-changes-comment-deadline.
- Clarin. “DHS Proposed H-1B Extension Rule: How Ending USCIS Deference Could Impact 208,000 Work Visa Renewals and Trigger 6,000 More RFEs.” November 2026. https://www.clarin.com/us-news/dhs-proposed-h-1b-extension-rule-how-ending-uscis-deference-could-impact-208000-work-visa-renewals-and-trigger-6000-mor
Perplexity
ChatGPT
Claude
Gemini









