November Relaunch: Opening on 1st November
Xender Facebook logo Linkedin logo Instagram logo Youtube logo
  (+1) 413 400 3003
WhatsApp
WhatsApp Message
Perplexity ChatGPT Claude Gemini

Why The New Wage-Based H-1B Could Face Legal Backlash: Is It The New O-1?

Perplexity ChatGPT Claude Gemini
Why The New Wage-Based H-1B Could Face Legal Backlash: Is It The New O-1?

The new H-1B visa rule remains one of the most important reforms amidst the crucial changes in the immigration policy under Donald Trump’s administration. Though the rule is going to be formally published and written down in the Federal Register today, much of it remains unclear and mysterious. Experts are already asking questions about whether the rule is going to supplant the old O-1 visa, and has even the potential to completely replace it.

Sounds surprising? Doesn't it? Here, our EB-1A green card consultancy explained what exactly we meant, along with a clear explanation.

H-1B visa is not for higher wages: this is a criterion for O-1

Recently, in a social media post, immigration attorney Emily Neumann argued, and rightly so, that the wage-based H-1B rule could face a myriad of legal challenges as the program was never meant to be a wage-based system. She further argued that the crux of the dispute is in this: whether the administration has the authority to prioritize higher-paid workers in a programme that, by law, does not consider wage a core criterion.

Interestingly, there is already a visa category in existence that requires a high salary as a criterion: this category is the O-1. According to Neumann, “The statute passed by Congress that created the H-1B visa made no requirement that the visas should go to high-wage individuals. There is already an O-1 visa category for people with extraordinary ability."

A confusion between H-1B and O-1 visa?

According to Neumann and several other immigration experts and lawyers, the statute by Congress that directly contributed to the origin of the H-1B visa made no requirement about the wages of the individuals. That requirement is, on the contrary, reserved for the O-1 visa.

H-1B visa only requires a bachelor’s degree or equivalent. And, by law, it should not ask for extraordinary ability or extraordinary remuneration.

On the other hand, the O-1 visa requires evidence of extraordinary ability and specialisation from the individual applicant. This visa is usually designed for those who can demonstrate extraordinary command in their respective niche or field, whether in science, education, business, arts, athletics, or other fields. Among the myriad O-1 visa criteria, the applicant also needs to show evidence of their high remuneration. This is often also similar to the EB-1A visa.

In all probability, following this very line of argument, Neumann has argued: “Now the administration is saying it has the authority to favour higher wages. That is the issue that is likely to be challenged."

Neumann brought yet another accusation aimed at the wage-based H-1B policy: “This time they followed the notice-and-comment procedure, but they finalised the rule without meaningfully engaging with the public.”

She pointed out that the proposal for wage-based selection was published on September 24 and remained open to public comment for only 60 days. Clearly, the window is too short to review all the comments adequately.

Hence, the question remains pertinent: when there is already an extraordinary ability visa, what is the point of turning the H-1B visa into another wage-based system? It almost seems redundant or seems like it is going to be yet another substitute for the O-1 visa system.

At GCEB1, we are continuously updating our audience with the latest news, analysis and developments in the international immigration landscape. Stay tuned to our blog section to get the most comprehensive analysis of the immigration issues. If you need suggestions, insights or tailored advice for the U.S. permanent residency, reach out to our EB-1A consultants directly. We wish you a smooth and stress-free immigration journey.

Sources & Further Readings

  1. The Times of India. “If H-1B Becomes Wage-Based, What Is O-1 Visa For?: Immigration Attorney Says New Rule May Run Into Legal Hurdles.” The Times of India, December 28, 2025.
  2. Reddy Neumann Brown PC. “Change in the H-1B Lottery: How Wages Now Shape the Odds.” RNLawGroup.com.
Recent Post
Canada Closes Ways for Parent, Grandparent Immigrations: Families Torn Apart
Canada Closes Ways for Parent, Grandparent Immigrations: Families Torn Apart

The Canadian administration put a harsh stop to the Parents and Grandparents Program (PGP) in 2026. In other words, it is continuing with a permanent pause as announced in the previous year.

Trump Extends H-1B Visa Restrictions With $100,000 Fee Push By Another Year
Trump Extends H-1B Visa Restrictions With $100,000 Fee Push By Another Year

President Donald Trump has extended, by another year, the restrictions he first imposed on the H-1B non-immigrant visa program in September 2025, the White House said in a proclamation released on Friday, September 18. The move, reported by Reuters' Kanishka Singh, keeps in place both a broad entry restriction on certain nonimmigrant workers and the administration's push to permanently raise H-1B filing costs to at least $100,000. It is up from a longstanding fee that had ranged between roughly $2,000 and $5,000, or as some tallies put it, $960 to $7,595 depending on petition type.
Goodbye, Open-Ended Stay: US Student Visa Change Could Reshape Study Plans for Thousands of Indians
Goodbye, Open-Ended Stay: US Student Visa Change Could Reshape Study Plans for Thousands of Indians

A major change to America's student visa system is now just a regulatory step away from becoming reality and it could significantly alter how long Indian students are allowed to stay in the United States. The White House Office of Management and Budget has cleared a final rule from the Department of Homeland Security that would scrap the decades-old "Duration of Status" (D/S) framework for F-1 and J-1 visa holders, and replace it with a fixed admission period.

USCIS Updates Policy On The Definition of Day in Case of Filing Deadline
USCIS Updates Policy On The Definition of Day in Case of Filing Deadline

U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services has issued new guidance that will change how the agency calculates certain filing deadlines that land on weekends or federal holidays. Immigration attorneys are saying that it could carry serious consequences for applicants racing against an age-based cutoff.

USCIS Sounds the Alarm: "It's a Scam": Why Promises of Faster Visas, Green Cards and Work Permits Should Worry You
USCIS Sounds the Alarm: "It's a Scam": Why Promises of Faster Visas, Green Cards and Work Permits Should Worry You

For anyone who has ever waited anxiously for a visa decision, the promise of "faster processing for a fee" can sound like a lifeline. But U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) has a blunt message for applicants tempted by such offers: it is probably an outright scam.
Trump Administration Unleashes Surprise Site Checks for OPT Students
Trump Administration Unleashes Surprise Site Checks for OPT Students

The U.S. administration has escalated the surveillance directed towards foreign students under the Optional Practical Training or OPT programme.
Trump's Proposed $100,000 OPT Fee: What It Means for Indian Students in America
Trump's Proposed $100,000 OPT Fee: What It Means for Indian Students in America

A proposal is reportedly under consideration by the Trump administration to impose a $100,000 fee on international students seeking to work in the United States after graduation. This news has rattled universities and employers alike, who warn it could upend the financial logic of an American education for hundreds of thousands of foreign students. The plan, first reported by the Wall Street Journal and later confirmed by Bloomberg, is not a full-blown policy yet. Officials at the Department of Homeland Security are reportedly discussing attaching the fee to Optional Practical Training (OPT), the program that lets international graduates work in the US for up to one year after finishing their degree (or up to three years for STEM graduates). It remains unclear whether the fee, if adopted, would fall on students, employers or universities.
U.S. Green Cards and Visa Holders to Face Photographing Vetting From December
U.S. Green Cards and Visa Holders to Face Photographing Vetting From December

The United States administration is about to implement photographic vetting of all non-citizens when they enter or exit the United States.
US Mandate for in-Person Visa Interviews to Take Effect from September 2025
US Mandate for in-Person Visa Interviews to Take Effect from September 2025

In a recent revision, the US has modified the interview waiver list and called upon the majority of non-immigrants to appear in person for immigration interviews.
Trump Releases Immigration Welfare Data: India Missing from The List
Trump Releases Immigration Welfare Data: India Missing from The List

In early January 2026, U.S. President Donald Trump shared a chart on his Truth Social platform revealing “Immigrant Welfare Recipient Rates by Country of Origin”. The graphic lists welfare participation rates for immigrant households from about 120 countries and territories in the United States. The surprising absence of India from the list became a focal point of analysis in both U.S. and international news.