April Relaunch: exclusive discounts coming soon
Xender Facebook logo Linkedin logo Instagram logo Youtube logo
  (+1) 469 463 5461
WhatsApp
WhatsApp Message

Why The New Wage-Based H-1B Could Face Legal Backlash: Is It The New O-1?

Why The New Wage-Based H-1B Could Face Legal Backlash: Is It The New O-1?

The new H-1B visa rule remains one of the most important reforms amidst the crucial changes in the immigration policy under Donald Trump’s administration. Though the rule is going to be formally published and written down in the Federal Register today, much of it remains unclear and mysterious. Experts are already asking questions about whether the rule is going to supplant the old O-1 visa, and has even the potential to completely replace it.

Sounds surprising? Doesn't it? Here, our EB-1A green card consultancy explained what exactly we meant, along with a clear explanation.

H-1B visa is not for higher wages: this is a criterion for O-1

Recently, in a social media post, immigration attorney Emily Neumann argued, and rightly so, that the wage-based H-1B rule could face a myriad of legal challenges as the program was never meant to be a wage-based system. She further argued that the crux of the dispute is in this: whether the administration has the authority to prioritize higher-paid workers in a programme that, by law, does not consider wage a core criterion.

Interestingly, there is already a visa category in existence that requires a high salary as a criterion: this category is the O-1. According to Neumann, “The statute passed by Congress that created the H-1B visa made no requirement that the visas should go to high-wage individuals. There is already an O-1 visa category for people with extraordinary ability."

A confusion between H-1B and O-1 visa?

According to Neumann and several other immigration experts and lawyers, the statute by Congress that directly contributed to the origin of the H-1B visa made no requirement about the wages of the individuals. That requirement is, on the contrary, reserved for the O-1 visa.

H-1B visa only requires a bachelor’s degree or equivalent. And, by law, it should not ask for extraordinary ability or extraordinary remuneration.

On the other hand, the O-1 visa requires evidence of extraordinary ability and specialisation from the individual applicant. This visa is usually designed for those who can demonstrate extraordinary command in their respective niche or field, whether in science, education, business, arts, athletics, or other fields. Among the myriad O-1 visa criteria, the applicant also needs to show evidence of their high remuneration. This is often also similar to the EB-1A visa.

In all probability, following this very line of argument, Neumann has argued: “Now the administration is saying it has the authority to favour higher wages. That is the issue that is likely to be challenged."

Neumann brought yet another accusation aimed at the wage-based H-1B policy: “This time they followed the notice-and-comment procedure, but they finalised the rule without meaningfully engaging with the public.”

She pointed out that the proposal for wage-based selection was published on September 24 and remained open to public comment for only 60 days. Clearly, the window is too short to review all the comments adequately.

Hence, the question remains pertinent: when there is already an extraordinary ability visa, what is the point of turning the H-1B visa into another wage-based system? It almost seems redundant or seems like it is going to be yet another substitute for the O-1 visa system.

At GCEB1, we are continuously updating our audience with the latest news, analysis and developments in the international immigration landscape. Stay tuned to our blog section to get the most comprehensive analysis of the immigration issues. If you need suggestions, insights or tailored advice for the U.S. permanent residency, reach out to our EB-1A consultants directly. We wish you a smooth and stress-free immigration journey.

Sources & Further Readings

  1. The Times of India. “If H-1B Becomes Wage-Based, What Is O-1 Visa For?: Immigration Attorney Says New Rule May Run Into Legal Hurdles.” The Times of India, December 28, 2025.
  2. Reddy Neumann Brown PC. “Change in the H-1B Lottery: How Wages Now Shape the Odds.” RNLawGroup.com.
Recent Post
U.S. To Introduce Visa Bond Pilot Program: Travelers Need to Pay $5K–$15K Deposit

In a move poised to reshape travel norms, the U.S. Department of State has launched a 12-month pilot visa bond program on August 20, 2025, targeting select B-1 (business) and B-2 (tourist) visa applicants.
How to Apply for a H-4 Visa Renewal: A Definitive Step-by-Step Guide

For families in the United States on H-1B visas, the H-4 visa is what allows spouses and children to stay together in the country legally. It provides dependents of H-1B workers the ability to live in the U.S., attend school, and, in some cases, even work through an H-4 EAD (Employment Authorization Document). However, the H-4 visa is not permanent. It must be renewed periodically whenever the H-1B holder extends their status or when the visa stamp expires. Previously, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) granted a 540-day automatic extension for the H-4 visas. However, with the recent cancellation of this period for certain visa categories, the H-4 visa holders need to remain more cautious than ever.
Top Benefits of the EB-1 Visa Compared to Other U.S. Green Card Options

Learn the differences between EB-1 , EB-2 and EB3 Employment-based visa, including their eligibility criteria.
Texas Governor Directs Freezing All H-1B Visa Petitions & Launches Investigation Into Visa Abuse

Texas Governor Greg Abbott has ordered a statewide H-1B visa freeze in a detailed letter to the public universities and the state agencies. As is well known, the program allows all foreign-born workers and students to legally reside and work in the United States. The statewide suspension of the H-1B visa has caused worries to many, as this move is thought to obstruct medical research and PhD programs that tend to rely heavily on the visa program to attract talent.

H-1B Visa Hiring Banned in Florida? Ron DeSantis Urges to Hire Americans

As an H-1B worker, you won’t get a job in Florida. Yes, you heard it right, as in a major offensive against immigrants, Florida has banned H-1B visa hiring.
EB-1A vs. EB-2 NIW vs. O-1A: Which Path Is Right for You?

Merit-based pathways are undoubtedly the best ways to secure permanent residency in the U.S. But, there are differences and variations within the merit-based pathways themselves. There are at least three merit-based immigration avenues in the U.S. that an applicant can pursue by leveraging their genius. In this blog, we break down these three prominent options: EB-1A, EB-2 NIW, and O-1A. In this overview, you will get a clear account of their criteria and some common use case scenarios.

Canada Teases TR-to-PR Pathway for 33,000 Temporary Workers: Alternative for H-1B Techies?

Canada’s immigration minister, Lena Metlege Diab, announced something long anticipated: the Temporary Resident to Permanent Resident in Canada pathway is now active. It is about to open the door for 33,000 foreign workers who are already filling different job roles in Canada.

GCEB1 Collaborates With Zaia Law for Informative Q&A Discussion on EB-1A Category

Last Sunday, on 15/03/2026, Guilherme Zaia from Zaia Law joined us for a highly enriching and instructive session where he elucidated several notions of the EB-1A category for our clients.

US Senator Mike Lee Airs Idea of Pausing H-1B Visa: What Should You Expect?

In a recent social media post, US Republican Senator Mike Lee has vented his desire to put a stop to the H-1B visa system. This is the visa system on which a large chunk of highly skilled Indian workers depend.
US Ends Interview Waiver (Dropbox) for Visas: A Turning Point for Indians Abroad

From September 2, 2025, the United States will roll back its Interview Waiver Programme, commonly known as the “Dropbox” facility, for most non-immigrant visas.